nav emailalert searchbtn searchbox tablepage yinyongbenwen piczone journalimg journalInfo journalinfonormal searchdiv searchzone qikanlogo popupnotification paper paperNew
2025, 12, 73-79
基于DEM联用Box-Behnken响应面法优化中速磨煤机衬板磨损性能的研究
基金项目(Foundation): 青海大学青年科研基金项目(2023-QGY-12)
邮箱(Email):
DOI: 10.20239/j.issn.1671-9492.2025.12.009
摘要:

针对ZMG113型中速磨煤机因煤粉颗粒冲蚀导致的严重磨损问题,基于离散元法(DEM)联用Box-Behnken响应面法研究了磨煤机运行参数对生产综合效益即磨煤机筒壁衬板单位时间磨损程度的影响。研究建立了风环风速、煤粉直径、衬板初始入射角与生产综合效益之间的回归方程数学模型,以3 s内衬板所受法向与切向累计能量之和的倒数作为综合效益,设计了包含17组试验的BBD方案,并建立二阶多项式回归模型,分析了单因素及多因素交互作用对衬板磨损的影响,并研究了两种不同结构衬板的响应效果。仿真结果表明,凸衬板模型响应回归方程的R2为0.92,平衬板模型响应回归方程的R2为0.97,可以较好反应各试验因素与磨煤机磨损程度之间的关系。从单因素来看,风环风速和衬板初始入射角的影响较大。从多因素来看,风环风速和衬板初始入射角的交互影响最明显。衬板初始入射角确定后,对于凸衬板模型,当颗粒直径为0.4 mm,风环速度为10 m/s时,磨煤机生产综合效益达到最大值;对于平衬板模型,风环风速为10 m/s时,煤粉直径为0.07 mm或0.5 mm时,综合效益达到最大值。相对于凸衬板模型,平衬板模型综合效益Q的最高点降低了18.08%,最低点上升了28.62%,即平衬板模型有效降低了磨煤机衬板严重磨损区域的磨损程度。本研究为磨煤机耐磨部件结构优化与运行参数调控提供了数据支撑与理论依据,对提升电厂制粉系统经济性与可靠性具有工程参考价值。

Abstract:

This paper addressed the severe wear issue of the ZMG113 medium-speed coal mill caused by coal particle erosion. Based on the Discrete Element Method(DEM) combined with the Box-Behnken Design(BBD) response surface methodology,the influence of operational parameters on the comprehensive production efficiencyspecifically,the wear rate per unit time of the mill liner-was investigated. A regression model was established to correlate the wind ring velocity,coal particle diameter,and initial impact angle of the liner with production efficiency,where the efficiency was defined as the reciprocal of the total cumulative normal and tangential energy absorbed by the liner within 3 seconds. A BBD experimental plan comprising 17 trials was designed,and a secondorder polynomial regression model was developed to analyze the effects of single factors and multi-factor interactions on liner wear. Additionally,the wear responses of two liner structures(convex and flat) were compared.Simulation results demonstrated that the regression model for the convex liner achieved an R2 of 0. 92,while the flat liner model yielded an R2 of 0. 97,indicating strong correlations between experimental factors and wear behavior. Single-factor analysis revealed that wind ring velocity and initial impact angle exerted the most significant influence. Multi-factor interaction analysis highlighted the dominant interplay between wind ring velocity and initial impact angle. For the convex liner,under a fixed initial impact angle,the optimal comprehensive efficiency was achieved at a particle diameter of 0. 4 mm and wind ring velocity of 10 m/s. For the flat liner,maximum efficiency occurred at a wind ring velocity of 10 m/s with particle diameters of either 0. 07 mm or 0. 5 mm. Compared to the convex liner,the flat liner exhibited an 18. 08% reduction in peak wear and a 28. 62% increase in minimum wear resistance,effectively mitigating severe wear in critical regions. This study provided data-driven insights and theoretical foundations for optimizing wear-resistant liner structures and operational parameters in coal mills,offering engineering significance for enhancing the economic efficiency and reliability of power plant pulverizing systems.

参考文献

[1]安普亮. ZGM113G型中速辊式磨煤机的应用[J].发电设备,2008,22(2):168-171.AN Puliang. Application of ZGM113G medium speed coal mills[J]. Power Equipment,2008,22(2):168-171.

[2]汪建新,杨婷,杜志强.基于EDEM的新型辊式振动破碎机破碎性能仿真研究[J].有色金属(选矿部分),2023(6):30-38.WANG Jianxin,YANG Ting,DU Zhiqiang. Simulation study of crushing performance of new roll type vibratory rock crusher based on EDEM[J]. Nonferrous Metals(Mineral Processing Section),2023(6):30-38.

[3]杨金林,莫凡,周文涛,等.选择性磨矿研究概述[J].矿产综合利用,2017(5):1-6.YANG Jinlin,MO Fan,ZHOU Wentao,et al. Review of research on selective grinding[J]. Multipurpose Utilization of Mineral Resources,2017(5):1-6.

[4]张剑锋,周志芳.摩擦磨损与抗磨技术[M].天津:天津科技翻译出版公司,1993:100-125.ZHANG Jianfeng,ZHOU Zhifang. Friction and wear and anti-wear technology[M]. Tianjin:Tianjin Science and Technology Translation Publishing Company,1993:100-125.

[5]郭主城,张福杰. MPS190-HP-Ⅱ型辊盘式中速磨煤机磨损分析及处理[J].东北电力技术,2015,36(3):35-37,62.GUO Zhucheng,ZHANG Fujie. Wearing analysis and solution to MPS190-HP-Ⅱroller disc medium-speed mill[J]. Northeast Electric Power Technology,2015,36(3):35-37,62.

[6]余海铭.中速磨煤机内部温度场数值模拟与试验研究[D].杭州:浙江大学,2014.YU Haiming. Industried-size measurements and numerical simulations of the temperature distribution within medium speed mills[D]. Hangzhou:Zhejiang University,2014.

[7]赵熙,阎维平,祝宪,等. 600 MW锅炉中速磨石子煤排放异常分析[J].锅炉技术,2010,41(2):61-64.ZHAO Xi,YAN Weiping,ZHU Xian,et al. Analysis on abnormal stone coal displacement of medium-speed mill of 600 MW boiler[J]. Boiler Technology,2010,41(2):61-64.

[8]吕强.关于减少RP923碗式中速磨煤机石子煤量的调整途径探讨[J].电站辅机,1993,14(4):16-18,27.LYU Qiang. Discussion on the adjustment way to reduce the amount of pebble coal in RP923 bowl type medium speed coal mill[J]. Power Station Auxiliary Equipment,1993,14(4):16-18,27.

[9]VUTHALURU R,KRUGER O,ABHISHEK M,et al. Investigation of wear pattern in a complex coal pulveriser using CFD modelling[J]. Fuel Processing Technology,2006,87(8):687-694.

[10]谢卓宏,张岁庚.半自磨机及球磨机衬板结构的改进[J].有色金属(选矿部分),2019(1):73-77.XIE Zhuohong,ZHANG Suigeng. The lining board redesign of SAG and ball mill[J]. Nonferrous Metals(Mineral Processing Section),2019(1):73-77.

[11]张谦,肖庆飞,赵福刚,等.球磨机衬板失效原因分析及优化对策研究[J].有色金属(选矿部分),2021(5):131-139,149.ZHANG Qian,XIAO Qingfei,ZHAO Fugang,et al.Failure analysis of ball mill liner and optimization countermeasure[J]. Nonferrous Metals(Mineral Processing Section),2021(5):131-139,149.

[12]甄琦,陈松利,万大千,等.挟沙风对风力发电机叶片冲蚀磨损的数值研究[J].太阳能学报,2022,43(7):257-263.ZHEN Qi,CHEN Songli,WAN Daqian,et al.Numerical research on erosion and wear of wind turbine blades in sand-carrying wind[J]. Acta Energiae Solaris Sinica,2022,43(7):257-263.

[13]孙岩,陈一鸣,王博,等.稠油输送管道90°弯管的冲蚀模拟分析[J].北京化工大学学报(自然科学版),2020,47(6):40-46.SUN Yan,CHEN Yiming,WANG Bo,et al. Erosion simulation analysis of a 90°elbow in a heavy oil pipeline[J]. Journal of Beijing University of Chemical Technology(Natural Science Edition),2020,47(6):40-46.

[14]徐鑫,吴玉国,孙岩.颗粒属性对输气管道渐缩管冲蚀磨损的仿真预测[J].辽宁石油化工大学学报,2020,40(3):45-51.XU Xin,WU Yuguo,SUN Yan. Simulation and prediction of particle property on erosion wear of specialshaped pipe fittings of gas transmission pipeline[J].Journal of Liaoning Shihua University,2020,40(3):45-51.

[15]王彦骅.输油管道典型管件冲蚀磨损数值模拟[D].抚顺:辽宁石油化工大学,2020.WANG Yanhua. Numerical simulation of erosion and wear of fluid-solid two-phase flow in collecting and transporting pipeline[D]. Fushun:Liaoning Shihua University,2020.

[16]王曼曼.磨煤机内部冲蚀磨损分析与堆焊防护技术研究[D].沈阳:沈阳理工大学,2023.WANG Manman. Analysis of erosion and wear in coal mill and research on protection technology of overlay welding[D]. Shenyang:Shenyang Ligong University,2023.

[17]周亚东,滕振超,刘凯琪,等.水砂两相流弯管接头处冲蚀磨损研究[J].当代化工,2022,51(7):1695-1699,1737.ZHOU Yadong,TENG Zhenchao,LIU Kaiqi,et al.Research on erosion wear at elbow joint of water-sand two-phase flow[J]. Contemporary Chemical Industry,2022,51(7):1695-1699,1737.

[18]谢文伟,邓建新,周后明,等.材料冲蚀磨损的数值模拟研究现状及展望[J].腐蚀与防护,2012(7):601-604.XIE Wenwei,DENG Jianxin,ZHOU Houming,et al.Development and prospect in numerical simulation of erosion[J]. Corrosion&Protection,2012(7):601-604.

[19]朱丽云,王森,王国涛,等.稠油热采四通管冲蚀特性影响因素数值模拟研究[J].表面技术,2022,51(11):244-252,270.ZHU Liyun,WANG Sen,WANG Guotao,et al. Numerical simulation of influence factors on erosion characteristics of four-way pipe in heavy oil thermal recovery[J]. Surface Technology,2022,51(11):244-252,270.

[20]孙小喆.气固两相流管道冲蚀安全判定边界研究[D].北京:中国石油大学(北京),2020.SUN Xiaozhe. Study on safety boundary of erosion in gas-solid two-phase flow pipeline[D]. Beijing:China University of Petroleum(Beijing),2020.

[21]BOX G E P,WILSON K B. On the experimental attainment of optimum conditions[J]. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series B:Statistical Methodology,1951,13(1):1-38.

基本信息:

DOI:10.20239/j.issn.1671-9492.2025.12.009

中图分类号:TD453;TH117.1

引用信息:

[1]林纪海,任姗姗,何生成,等.基于DEM联用Box-Behnken响应面法优化中速磨煤机衬板磨损性能的研究[J].有色金属(选矿部分),2025(12):73-79.DOI:10.20239/j.issn.1671-9492.2025.12.009.

基金信息:

青海大学青年科研基金项目(2023-QGY-12)

发布时间:

2025-05-08

出版时间:

2025-05-08

网络发布时间:

2025-05-08

检 索 高级检索

引用

GB/T 7714-2015 格式引文
MLA格式引文
APA格式引文